Half Life 2 GPU Roundup Part 1 - DirectX 9 Shootout
by Anand Lal Shimpi on November 17, 2004 11:22 AM EST- Posted in
- GPUs
Head to Head: ATI Radeon X800 Pro vs. NVIDIA GeForce 6800GT
Priced at $400 our next head to head comparison is between the 12-pip Radeon X800 Pro and the 16-pipe GeForce 6800GT.
In our first demo, the 6800GT pulls ahead in all of the resolutions:
| Half Life 2 AT_canals_08.dem | |||
ATI Radeon X800 Pro |
NVIDIA GeForce 6800GT |
Performance Advantage |
|
| 1024 x 768 | 125.6 |
133.3 |
6.1% |
| 1280 x 1024 | 101 |
110.8 |
9.7% |
| 1600 x 1200 | 82.3 |
88 |
6.9% |
| 1024 x 768 - 4X AA | 106.8 |
113.2 |
6.0% |
| 1280 x 1024 - 4X AA | 75.4 |
77.1 |
2.3% |
| Winner | - |
- |
6800GT |
Our second demo shows a much closer competition, with the X800 Pro pulling ahead in the highest resolution AA test:
| Half Life 2 AT_coast_05.dem | |||
ATI Radeon X800 Pro |
NVIDIA GeForce 6800GT |
Performance Advantage |
|
| 1024 x 768 | 133.1 |
131.3 |
1.4% |
| 1280 x 1024 | 124.8 |
123.8 |
0.8% |
| 1600 x 1200 | 110.7 |
109.1 |
1.5% |
| 1024 x 768 - 4X AA | 130.5 |
129.5 |
0.8% |
| 1280 x 1024 - 4X AA | 113.4 |
107.7 |
5.3% |
| Winner | - |
- |
X800 Pro |
The balance shifts over to NVIDIA once again, but the two perform very similarly here as well:
| Half Life 2 AT_coast_12.dem | |||
ATI Radeon X800 Pro |
NVIDIA GeForce 6800GT |
Performance Advantage |
|
| 1024 x 768 | 119 |
123.3 |
3.6% |
| 1280 x 1024 | 105.1 |
107.8 |
2.6% |
| 1600 x 1200 | 86.2 |
90.5 |
5.0% |
| 1024 x 768 - 4X AA | 111.4 |
112.2 |
0.7% |
| 1280 x 1024 - 4X AA | 84.5 |
86 |
1.8% |
| Winner | - |
- |
6800GT |
The 6800GT takes it once again in our fourth demo:
| Half Life 2 AT_prison_05.dem | |||
ATI Radeon X800 Pro |
NVIDIA GeForce 6800GT |
Performance Advantage |
|
| 1024 x 768 | 135.7 |
147.4 |
8.6% |
| 1280 x 1024 | 106 |
112 |
5.7% |
| 1600 x 1200 | 80.8 |
83.2 |
3.0% |
| 1024 x 768 - 4X AA | 111.3 |
118 |
6.0% |
| 1280 x 1024 - 4X AA | 82.5 |
79.8 |
3.4% |
| Winner | - |
- |
6800GT |
And in our final demo the X800 Pro comes away with the win.
| Half Life 2 AT_c17_12.dem | |||
ATI Radeon X800 Pro |
NVIDIA GeForce 6800GT |
Performance Advantage |
|
| 1024 x 768 | 88.1 |
84.6 |
4.1% |
| 1280 x 1024 | 84.6 |
84 |
0.7% |
| 1600 x 1200 | 79.2 |
77 |
2.9% |
| 1024 x 768 - 4X AA | 84.8 |
82.8 |
2.4% |
| 1280 x 1024 - 4X AA | 77.1 |
72.6 |
6.2% |
| Winner | - |
- |
X800 Pro |
Averaging all of the scores together tells us that the 6800GT and the X800 Pro basically perform identically to one another, regardless of resolution:
| Summary | |||
Average Performance Advantage (6800GT over X800 Pro) |
|||
| 1024 x 768 | 2.6% |
||
| 1280 x 1024 | 3.3% |
||
| 1600 x 1200 | 2.1% |
||
| 1024 x 768 - 4X AA | 1.9% |
||
| 1280 x 1024 - 4X AA | -0.8% |
||
Head to Head: ATI Radeon X800 XT vs. NVIDIA GeForce 6800 Ultra
Head to Head: ATI Radeon X700 XT vs. NVIDIA GeForce 6600GT
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
79 Comments
View All Comments
Anand Lal Shimpi - Wednesday, November 17, 2004 - link
Thanks for all of the comments guys. Just so you know, I started on Part 2 the minute the first article was done. I'm hoping to be done with testing by sometime tomorrow and then I've just got to write the article. Here's a list of the new cards being tested:9600XT, 9550, 9700, X300, GF 6200, GF 5900XT, GF4 Ti 4600, GF4 MX440
I'm doing both DX9 and DX8 comparisons, including image quality.
After Part 2 I think I'll go ahead and do the CPU comparison, although I've been thinking about doing a more investigative type of article into Half Life 2 performance in trying to figure out where its performance limitations exist, so things may get shuffled around a bit.
We used the PCI Express 6600GT for our tests, but the AGP version should perform quite similarly.
The one issue I'm struggling with right now is the fact that the X700 XT is still not available in retail, while the X700 Pro (256MB) is. If I have the time I may go back and run some X700 Pro numbers to make this a more realistic present-day comparison.
Any other requests?
Take care,
Anand
Cybercat - Wednesday, November 17, 2004 - link
You guys made my day comparing the X700XT, 6800, and 6600GT together. One question though (and I apologize if this was mentioned in the article and I missed it), did you guys use the PCIe or AGP version of the 6600GT?Houdani - Wednesday, November 17, 2004 - link
18: Many users rely on hardware review sites to get a feel for what technology is worth upgrading and when.Most of us have financial contraints which preclude us from upgrading to the best hardware, therefore we are more interested in knowing how the mainstream hardware performs.
You are correct that it would not be an efficient use of resources to have AT repeat the tests on hardware that is two or three generations old ... but sampling the previous generation seems appropriate. Fortunately, that's where part 2 will come in handy.
I expect that part 2 will be sufficient in showing whether or not the previous generation's hardware will be a bottleneck. The results will be invaluable for helping me establish my minimum level of satisfaction for today's applications.
stelleg151 - Wednesday, November 17, 2004 - link
forget what i said in 34.....pio!pio! - Wednesday, November 17, 2004 - link
So how do you softmod a 6800NU to a 6800GT???or unlock the extra stuff....
stelleg151 - Wednesday, November 17, 2004 - link
What drivers were being used here, 4.12 + 67.02??Akira1224 - Wednesday, November 17, 2004 - link
Jedilol I should have seen that one coming!
nastyemu25 - Wednesday, November 17, 2004 - link
i bought a 9600XT because it came boxed with a free coupon for HL2. and now i can't even see how it matches up :(coldpower27 - Wednesday, November 17, 2004 - link
These benchmarks are more in line with what I was predicting, the x800 Pro should be equal to 6800 GT due to similar Pixel Shader fillrate while the X800 XT should have an advantage at higher resolutions due to it's having a higher fillrate being clocked higher.Unlike DriverATIheaven:P.
This is great I am happy knowing Nvidia's current generation of hardware is very competitive in performance in all aspects when at equal amounts of fillrate.
Da3dalus - Wednesday, November 17, 2004 - link
In the 67.02 Forceware driver there's a new option called "Negative LOD bias", if I understand what I've read correctly it's supposed to reduce shimmering.What was that option set to in the tests? And how did it affect performance, image quality and shimmering?